Blog Post

What are Preference and Insider Payments?

Timothy M. Hughes • May 18, 2020
Under bankruptcy law, all creditors of the same priority need to be treated equally by the debtor. When a debtor repays one creditor and not others, it is considered a “preference” because the debtor is providing special treatment to a single creditor. All creditors of the same priority need to be treated equally under bankruptcy law. If a debtor pays one person or one entity and not others, the bankruptcy trustee has the right to void that transaction and bring the money back into the debtor’s bankruptcy estate so that all the debtor’s creditors will be paid the same percentage. The preference period for a normal creditor (i.e. credit card companies) is 90 days versus one year for an insider because transactions with insiders are more closely scrutinized. The question of whether a creditor is considered an “insider” in a bankruptcy case is an important distinction.

If a debtor has repaid a creditor a significant amount of money before filing for bankruptcy, it is important to disclose the transaction(s) related to the payment(s) in detail. This includes identifying the payees who are insiders. The bankruptcy code defines an “insider” to include a relative of the debtor or a general partner of the debtor. And “relative” is defined to mean an individual related by affinity or consanguinity within the third degree as determined by the common law, or an individual in a step or adoptive relationship within such third degree. 

Courts have also defined insider more broadly to include a close family friend (but not relative), Courts have also looked at whether there is a close enough relationship between the debtor and the creditor that their transactions should be scrutinized at more than regular arms-length transactions. The courts look at whether the creditor could exert any influence over the debtor. If the creditor has some control over the debtor, then the creditor could be defined as an “insider.”  

In addition to possibly undoing preference payments described above, a bankruptcy trustee has Avoidance Powers to go back four years to undo a transaction if there was a fraudulent transfer or transfer for less than fair market value. The chapter 7 bankruptcy trustee is an individual appointed by the Department of Justice to oversee the administration of a chapter 7 bankruptcy case. The trustee’s main duty is to examine the debtor under oath to determine whether or not there are any assets to be administered for the benefit of creditors. In most chapter 7 bankruptcy cases, there are no assets for a trustee to administer. This is because the state of Illinois exemption laws provide debtors with the ability to protect a specific amount of personal property while going through the bankruptcy process. However, the trustee also has avoidance powers. These powers give him the ability to undo certain transactions if it was done under two specific scenarios: 1) Fraudulent Transfers -- an act(s) made with actual intent to hinder, delay or defraud creditors, and 2) Transferred Asset For Less Than Fair Market Value – an act(s) made for less than the fair market value by a debtor who was insolvent at the time of the transfer.

If you would like more details, please do not hesitate to call our office. Our office has been successful in helping consumers with collection problems for over 28 years. If you have a debt or tax problem, please contact me at (847) 705-9698 or thughes@lavellelaw.com and find out how. we can help you. We are a debt relief agency. We help people file for bankruptcy relief under the Bankruptcy Code. 

More News & Resources

Lavelle Law News and Events

LATEST UPDATE on the Corporate Transparency Act and New Deadline for Filing BOIR
By Frank J. Portera February 20, 2025
This article will serve as another update to the ongoing Corporate Transparency Act developments. As of February 17, 2025, a federal judge in the Eastern District of Texas lifted the injunction it had ordered on January 7, 2025, in Smith v. U.S. Department of the Treasury, 6:24-cv-00336 (E.D. Tex.), allowing the federal government to once again enforce the Corporate Transparency Act and its Beneficial Ownership Information Report requirements.
A Step-by-Step Guide to Bringing a Lawsuit in Illinois
By Sarah J. Reusché February 14, 2025
This article is the second in our Litigation 101 series. It focuses on the flip side: how to sue someone else. Suing someone is a serious decision that requires careful thought and preparation. Before pursuing legal action, it’s crucial to reflect on the issue and understand the steps involved in bringing a lawsuit. This article outlines the basics to help you approach the process with confidence and make informed decisions.
Updates Regarding the Corporate Transparency Act Hold: Key Implications for Businesses
By Frank J. Portera February 13, 2025
On December 11, 2024, we published an article titled “Corporate Transparency Act on Hold: Key Implications for Businesses,” which addressed the nationwide injunction impacting the enforcement of the Corporate Transparency Act and its Beneficial Ownership Information Reporting rule. Since then, there have been a few significant legal developments that businesses should monitor closely. While the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network is currently prohibited from enforcing BOIR requirements, ongoing litigation, and the related appeals may alter this status. Below, we provide a timeline of key events and insights into what business owners should anticipate moving forward.
IRS Special Payments Sent to 1 Million Taxpayers Who Did Not Claim 2021 Recovery Rebate Credit
By Timothy M. Hughes February 10, 2025
The Internal Revenue Service is issuing automatic payments to eligible people who did not claim a Recovery Rebate Credit on their 2021 tax returns. The payments are in follow up to an IRS announcement last month of the intent to take this special step. The IRS took this step after reviewing internal data showing many eligible taxpayers who filed a return but did not claim the credit. The Recovery Rebate Credit is a refundable credit for individuals who did not receive one or more Economic Impact Payments (“EIP”), also known as stimulus payments.
SCOTUS Resolves Circuit Split on FLSA Exemption Standard
By Steven A. Migala February 5, 2025
The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) establishes federal minimum wage and overtime pay requirements, with exemptions for employees in bona fide executive, administrative, professional, computer or outside sales roles. 29 U.S.C. § 213. Employees classified as "outside sales" must primarily engage in making sales or obtaining contracts for services or the use of facilities, and they must conduct their work primarily away from their employer’s place of business. 29 C.F.R. § 541.500.
Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act (BIPA)
By Sarah J. Reusché January 23, 2025
Amendments to BIPA SB 2929 became effective on August 2, 2024. Codified as 740 ILCS 14/10 and 14/20, this Act introduced two pivotal changes to BIPA that dealers should be aware of: • Limiting Per-Scan Damages: The amendments clarify that a single violation under BIPA accrues per type of violation, rather than per scan. This significantly reduces the financial exposure for dealerships. • Electronic Consent: The amendments formalize electronic signatures as a valid means of securing biometric consent, streamlining compliance processes for businesses.
IRS National Taxpayer Advocate Releases Annual Report to Congress. And in an Unrelated Matter DOJ Ta
By Timothy M. Hughes January 10, 2025
The National Taxpayer Advocate recently released her annual report to Congress. A few highlights from the report are summarized in this article.
Nearly 300 New Illinois Laws are going into effect in 2025.
By Lavelle Law January 8, 2025
Nearly 300 New Illinois Laws are going into effect in 2025. Listed below are some that may have a significant impact on you or your business.
Happy New Year and Cheers to New Adventures in 2025!
By Lavelle Law December 31, 2024
As we say farewell to 2024, we’re excited to look back on the unforgettable moments from our Koozie Challenge! From the frozen wonders of Antarctica to the excitement of the Paris Olympics, and countless incredible destinations in between, the Lavelle Law koozie truly went the distance this year! A big thank you to our clients, staff, family, and friends who took part in the fun. Here’s to even more adventures in 2025! Happy New Year from Lavelle Law!
Lavelle Law concludes the 2024 annual food drive.
By Lavelle Law December 30, 2024
Schaumburg-based Lavelle Law wrapped its annual food drive benefiting the Schaumburg Township Food Pantry. During the month of October, Lavelle Law set up collection boxes around Schaumburg and the surrounding area, where residents and workers could drop off nonperishable food items, paper goods, personal care items, baby food and diapers. Participants could also make cash donations online.
More Posts
Share by: